905 views
New Reviewer
42 comments
stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full stars-rating-full
3.0

Now what did you change a perfectly good cookie just the way it was ? This was a totally dumb move..

If you wanted a new type of cookie, then you should have introduced the new cookie on its own, and left the original Pinwheel the way it was. I am not buying the new recipe cookie, they taste terrible !!!!!

You need to put the cookie back to the original and leave it alone. Now you just totally ruined a perfectly good product by changing it !

Reason of review: Bad quality.

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution.

Nabisco Cons: Your new pinwheel, Bring back the original.

Location: Portland, Oregon

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review

Comments

chat-icon

Please avoid publishing any personal information and promotional content

You will be automatically registered on our site. Username and password will be sent to you via email.
Post Comment
Hadyn Goy

when did they change the formula? i haven't seen them in walmart or fred meyers

Guest

Found the original Nabisco Pinwheel cookies at my local grocery store today. They say, "Pure Chocolate" on package.

Bought them, took them home and tried one and they, in fact, are the original delicious recipe I remember from the early 1960's! Than you Nabisco! Please don't ever change back to the new recipe that says "fudge"...they're horrible.

Original Pinwheels are divine...the best, most delicious cookies on the planet! Thank you!

Guest

I AGREE TOTALLY

Guest

I completely agree the new pinwheel recipe is horrible!! Bring back the original recipe of these cookies please.

I do not understand why you change the recipe when it was perfect the way it was. I will not buy the new pinwheel cookies. My mother used to buy the original Nabisco pinwheel cookies back in the early sixties and put them in my lunch when I was a child and they were delicious.

I've been buying them as an adult for years and they've been my most favorite cookie on the planet. Bring back the original recipe of these cookies please.

Guest

I've been eating pinwheels since I was 5. The new recipe sucks so much!! Bring back the old recipe.

Guest

Completely agree! These are similar to the "Twirl" cookies that Nabisco used to bake in the warmer months.

They had a chocolatey coating that wouldn't melt and a cake base with preservatives.

They looked like Pinwheels, but they sucked just like these new cookies. To call these new substitutes "Pinwheel" is actually fraudulent.

Guest

I agree with everyone on here! This new recipe SUCKS!

Why in the world would you change a good thing? As they say, if it ain't broke, don't fix it! I seriously thought something was wrong with the package I bought, took it back, got another one and it was the same.

Made me sick! Will not buy anymore.

Guest

Why change a good thing? Bring back the original pinwheels in their original package! The new ones are not as good.

Guest

PUT THAT COOKIE DOWN!!

Guest

I totally agree!

Guest

these pinwheell cookies taste like unwanted chemicals. what happened to the huge fluffy marshmallow with deep dark choclate coating cookies ? These new pinwheels taste like pure garbage.the tanned choclate coating looks sickening.

Guest

Can't believe they changed the best cookie ever, no more for me, they are disgusting!!!! Everyone I talk to is so disappointed.

I seriously use to eat 4-5 in a sitting.....

could even get those other ones down..... BRING BACK THE OLD RECEIPE

Guest

I loved pinwheels since I was a kid. I was so excited when I purchased a package at the low low price of $4.99.

HORRIBLE!!! Took one bit of this new recipe...spit it out and took the rest back. Nabisco needs to get their act together and bring back the old recipe. FYI DO NOT throw out your cookies.

Return them to the store you purchased them.

They have to take them back and the store gets 100% credit back from the vendor. When nabisco starts to see the amount of product they are getting back and the amount of money they are throwing in the trash ( right where the cookies belong) maybe they will wake up and bring back the old recipe

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1211726

I just called Nabisco. They are going back to the original recipe, though they don't have a specific date.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1219098

Yes You are right the pinwheel cookie is back on store shelves here in Illinois Look for the pure chocolate label. That is the original recipe if it says pure chocolate on the label. If you can't find them look for mallomars they have the same taste

Guest

We have bought pinwheel cookies many times and have always enjoyed them when they were made with real chocolate. Hate

The new recipe for this cookie and won't buy these cookies again.

Am throwing the one's we have bought with the new recipe

As they taste old and are disgusting.

Mary Ann

Guest

I didn't need to be eating cookies anyway, I guess. I tried one, just awful.

I'm throwing the rest of the bag away.

I'm sure this was a cost-cutting measure, changing to "fudge" instead of chocolate. I'm sure disappointed.

Guest

Hate the new recipe, won't buy them again! Total waste of over four dollars.

Guest

Agreed... The new recipe is awful!!!!!!!!

Chocolate was dark and rich... Now it is anemic in color and the taste is anemic.

Why did you change this?????

Guest

The new Pinwheel recipe is horrible. I took one *** and spit it out.

Threw the rest in the trash. I feel like I've been cheated.

View more comments (22)

Nabisco Reviews

  1. 577 reviews
  2. 221 reviews
  3. 183 reviews
  4. 128 reviews
  5. 128 reviews
Nabisco reviews