Manufacturer: Nabisco Category: Cookies Clear all filters (134 of 134 reviews match)
filters
manufacturer:
seller:
Show
state:
Show
city:
Show
category:
The new pinwheels are terrible. Used to be my favorite cookie, but I won't buy them any more. I wrote to the company and they sent me a coupon for free cookies, but the coupon wasn't enough to cover the cost. I see I need to write more words so I'll explain further. They changed the chocolate. It used to be dark chocolate and very good. Now it is milk chocolate and doesn't compare. There were other problems with the taste and consistency...
Read more
Nabisco in their managements wisdom thought they needed to change the recipe. Not sure what they were going for here outside of obvious cost cutting and profits. The cookies are terrible! They are smaller, softer, and taste nothing like the brand I have bought for over 40 years. I don't know how they can still call them pinwheels. Maybe the younger generations will give Nabisco some incremental sales and short term profits with the new design...
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous The new pinwheel cookies suck.i will not buy another

2.0
I liked
  • Recipe of the original cookie
  • Original cookie
#925560
I have been buying Pinwheels since the early 40's when they came in large paperboard boxes and were displayed on a special rack in our neighborhood grocery store. Whoever decided to change the Pinwheels into fresh look and new recipe cookies is an ***. I would use other descriptions, but those words are BAD. The new cookies are dreadful, awful, and not worth buying at any price. Please consider returning to the old recipe. .
Read more

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#947216
I love the original pin wheels. Why do companies mess with best cookies. I tried the new one. You people are crazy. I introduced the original cookie and now none of us eat the new ones. They were so expensive for cookies but worth it! These are so awful you would have to pay me. Very sad. GO BACK jan Janiswvr@gmail.com
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#937508
What a waste of money. I like the pinwheel cookies until I bought some yesterday. Noticed new recipe. Thought I would try them. I did not like them at all. If I could of returned then I would. Won't be buying those again.
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#934923
5.0
I'm 68. Pinwheel was my favorite winter snack. Waited patiently for them to arrive. The new pinwheel taste like a bad imitation. Please return to original receipt. Increase price if you must.
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#932902
Why have you ruined my pinwheels? YUK. I wont be buying them anymore. They leave a nasty taste in your mouth. I almost spit it out. Please fix this.
Comment
Show
I am 64 yrs old .The pinwheel was my Dads & my favorite cookie to share !! I had two younger brothers & this cookie was something special we shared together !!! No brothers allowed.....my Dad passed away in 2004 and at least once a year I bought a bag just tore mender my dad & our special cookie. I share with both my grown kids & they always think of their Grandpa Kubi. I just opened the bog without reading it-- but I noticed it looked like a...
Read more

Featured

Missing the Dark Chocolate, they are smashed smaller, the marshmallow is not even the same, it's flat and chewy, not full and fluffy like they used to be, and they are smaller in the same container and same price as before, and don't taste nearly the same. Why are you changing the recipe anyway, why fix what's not broken. these are expensive cookies at $5 for a dozen. if you want more people to buy more cookies, lower the price, don't change...
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous They don't want people to buy more cookies. They want people to buy more stock. By ripping you off, publicly traded companies show higher revenue than giving you a quality pro...

How very dissapointing. The new recipe is as bad as all the knock offs created over the years. I will be returning the cookies and am a very disappointed consumer. These cookies were a favorite of my family for as long as I can remember. Nabisco has taken this cookie from high quality ingredients to cheap, poor quality and the cookies are smaller at the same price point. Nabisco should be ashamed. .
Read more
Hi I have loved and eaten Nabisco pinwheel cookies! They have been my favorite until now.Please Please Please bring the original back!!! The chocolate in the new isn't nearly as good as the original. Plus its so much like the cheaper brand for 1.99. One of my brothers is already doing so. He says he can't tell the differance. So place come back with the old ones. Mark them up more if that will help! Jo Ann.
Read more
I recently bought a package of your "new" pinwheel cookies, they are awful, what did you do, gone are the dark chocolate, fluffy covered marshmallow cookies that were so delectable!!I only bought these on special occasions as they are expensive, you have now reduced them to the taste and quality of a much cheaper brand that I can get at the dollar store, PLEASE put them back to what they were. I can't see me ever buying these cookies again...
Read more
My purchase today was extremely disappointing. You changed the cookie. The fudge is cheap tasting, no different than a dollar box of cookies. Should have never changed the recipe will never buy them again. Very disappointed. Sometimes change is not worth it when you have an awesome product to begin with. Makes me wonder what you've done with all the other nabisco brands. Please consider changing back. Very diappointed customer. Lost forever!!!.
Read more
Dayle

Dayle I agree they are awful!

I purchased the new Pinwheel cookie last night and no words can express the disapointment...they were a disaster!I was unaware the recipe had changed. I just want to know when they are going back to the original recipe? I won't be buying anymore till then. As matter of fact I am calling customer service for a refund. I see no point in consuming calories for something that taste that bad!Poor quality and cost more...sad.
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous I bought a pkg of pinwheel cookies and looked forward to a special treat but after the first couple bites i had to check the date on the pkg.They have ruined this cookie by c...