Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Reviews

Nabisco Pinwheels  Cookies 1 of 2
2.2
(44 reviews)
Product or Service Quality
Value for money
Advertised vs Delivered
filters
seller:
Show
state:
Show
city:
Show
Why did you change the Pinwheel cookies?They taste like powdered chemicals. They are horrible. I want the cookies that I remember as a kid, with fluffy marshmallow and a real dark chocolate shell. I'm willing to pay extra just for the old ones. Please change them back. The new ones stick like glue to your tongue and the inside of your mouth. They are difficult to swallow and taste like chemical cardboard. What is wrong with you? You ruined the...
Read more
I liked
  • Old pinwheel cookies
#954078
I have been enjoying Pinwheels since I was a child and I'm 68 years old. To be perfectly frank the new pinwheels suck. How could a company as large and rich in history as Nabisco compromise the quality of a product to this degree? Is the bottom line the only important aspect to you? I will never be happy until you bring back the original cookies both in size and ingredient content. Putting "real chocolate" on an inferior cookie is not the...
Read more
1.0
I liked
  • Original pinwheel
  • Original dark chocolate pinwheels
#946079
I absolutely hate the new recipe! The old ones with dark chocolate were so good, I could eat the whole pkg. I bought some today, took 2 bites and threw it out. My son did the same. Why would you change a recipe when the old one was just right. It's too bad for me, I guess, cause I won't buy them again. I found them to be very bland, and also smaller all around. I asked opinions of people I know and they all agree and have stopped buying...
Read more
I didn't like
  • Quality and taste
#941114
The new pinwheel cookie now tastes like the cheap imatation cookies you can get for half the price. The original pinwheels were a splurge for me but so worth it. Please bring them back. .
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous I'm assuming they have changed the recipe back to the original on the Pinwheels. I bought the original at Walmart this past weekend. They are like the old ones. Package is the...

Not sure how the ingredients are different, but they have way too much corn syrup in them, for one thing. Maybe they're made in China. Clearly they're cheaper than the old ones. The chocolate coating looks dusty and may were broken even though they don't expire for two more months. It's sad when a company changes its recipe to make more profit and produces a far inferior product ruining a long-time favorite. I'm really sorry I bought these, but I won't make that mistake again. I think I'll avoid all Nabisco...
Read more
Fellow Pinwheel Cookie lovers, I was at my local grocery store today, happened to be in the cookie aisle, and thought I'd check out the Pinwheel Cookies to see if the Nabisco/Mondelez company was still trying to pass off their "New Fudge Recipe" with the marshmallow cookies covered in some type of inferior, cheap, disgusting sludge/fudge topping. (I had written and called the company to let them know of my disappointment in the change in...
Read more
5.0
I didn't like
  • New pinwheels recipe
#935765
I have been buying Nabisco Pinwheel cookies since the early 1980s.The perfect taste balance - justified the price. I was horrified to find that they had changed my all time favorite into a bland milk chocolate version. This version tastes a bit like the ones Nabisco used to sell during the warmer months with higher paraffin so the chocolate coating did not melt as easily. I have bought this cookie for 36 years, please change it back,it was so...
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous I will not buy the "new" Nabisco Pinwheel fudge cookies----------yuk! not good at all Why the change?

4.0
I liked
  • Pinwheel
  • Nabisco is out
  • Recipe of the original cookie
I didn't like
  • New fudge recipe
  • This will cost you lost sales and customers nabisco
  • Pinwheels
#933948
Why did you change the recipe? My husband and I loved, loved the original PINWHEEL!!!!!! The chocolate is way too milk chocolate unlike the great darker chocolate in the original Pinwheel. The bottom cookie is too bland and mushy feel when you *** into it. I purchased my first package yesterday and each cookie was sticking to each other. When you pulled it apart, the bottom of one cookie pulled off part of the top of the other cookie. Please...
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous I just bought a package of the pinwheels and I have to say that I am not a fan of the new recipe. I really liked the dark chocolate over the marshmallow cookie. I will not ...

I liked
  • Loved the original taste and high standards of your products
  • Original dark chocolate pinwheels
I didn't like
  • New recipe of pinwheels
#931968
The new pinwheels are terrible. Used to be my favorite cookie, but I won't buy them any more. I wrote to the company and they sent me a coupon for free cookies, but the coupon wasn't enough to cover the cost. I see I need to write more words so I'll explain further. They changed the chocolate. It used to be dark chocolate and very good. Now it is milk chocolate and doesn't compare. There were other problems with the taste and consistency...
Read more

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#949749
Your new recipes for pinwheel cookies is awful, they used to be my favorite, and now the chocolate is bas
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#949511
In a word...TERRIBLE. Absolutely terrible. Why did you change the recipe?? I am returning these monstrosities and never getting them again unless you go back to the original recipe. Remember New Coke?? That worked really well too...sarcasm. Very disappointed.
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#948935
Smaller. Not nearly as good. Very very disappointed.
Comment
Show

Nabisco Pinwheels Cookies Review

#947216
I love the original pin wheels. Why do companies mess with best cookies. I tried the new one. You people are crazy. I introduced the original cookie and now none of us eat the new ones. They were so expensive for cookies but worth it! These are so awful you would have to pay me. Very sad. GO BACK jan Janiswvr@gmail.com
Comment
Show
Nabisco in their managements wisdom thought they needed to change the recipe. Not sure what they were going for here outside of obvious cost cutting and profits. The cookies are terrible! They are smaller, softer, and taste nothing like the brand I have bought for over 40 years. I don't know how they can still call them pinwheels. Maybe the younger generations will give Nabisco some incremental sales and short term profits with the new design...
Read more
Anonymous

Anonymous The new pinwheel cookies suck.i will not buy another

2.0
I liked
  • Original cookie
  • Recipe of the original cookie
I didn't like
  • Changes in pinwheels
  • Nabisco no longer seems to care about quality
#925560